
"It's difficult to exaggerate the size of the task BMW undertook when it decided, five years ago, to build a full-on superbike. For years, the big four – Honda Fireblade, Suzuki GSX-R1000, Yamaha R1 and Kawasaki ZX-10R – have all reflected the excellence of Japanese motorcycle engineering. Their astonishing performance is a perfect complement to levels of reliability and quality that manufacturers of less stressed machines rarely reach.
Buyers in this sector look first at outright performance: the bike with the quickest lap time will win in the showrooms, irrespective of how relevant that might be to everyday riding. Heritage and race pedigree count for something, but riders are generally happy to swap marques each year, so any bike will suffer if it is not perceived as being up to scratch.
BMW doesn't have the required heritage, so merely matching its rivals would barely be adequate. It would still be impressive, though, to enter the arena as an equal from the outset. BMW's history of launching four-cylinder motorcycles, however, is woeful – the first was the K100 in 1984, and it took years to sort all the niggles and problems, while our K1200S report in July 2004 was the most negative review of a mainstream motorcycle ever to appear in Telegraph Motoring. It was horrible to ride, so BMW postponed its introduction by six months to put things right. It has since evolved so far that the K1300 variants are now among the best in their classes.
But consumers in the S 1000 RR class have too many top-notch alternatives. There can be no concessions, no apologies, no allowances – but none are needed.
Even the detailing moves things forward: the damping adjusters on the Sachs suspension (another newcomer to this level, and just as impressive as the rest of the bike) are colour-coded for rebound and compression adjustment with simple, numbered markings to simplify set-up. It's easy to adjust, and then you're rewarded with comprehensive feedback and imperious wheel control.
There's a whole feature to be written about the bike's technical details – see my website www.ashonbikes.com if you're interested – while its basic format of in-line, four-cylinder motor with twin spar, aluminium frame is generic superbike. The F1-style cam followers, array of butterfly valves in the exhaust and those electronics single it out as the most technologically advanced of all, yet the rider has not been forgotten in the process.
Comfort is Fireblade-good from the generously proportioned ergonomics, feedback from chassis and motor is perfect and the electronics enhance and protect rather than detracting from the experience.
Incredibly, even the price is on the pace. At £10,950 for the base model, the S 1000 RR is cheaper than a Yamaha R1 and competitive against the rest, while £12,235 for the fully equipped Sport feels like something of a bargain.
BMW's new superbike, right first time: not something I ever thought I'd be writing.
THE FACTS
Price/on sale: From £10,950/January 2010
Power/torque: 190bhp@13,000rpm/83lb ft@9,750rpm
Top speed: 185mph (est)
Fuel tank/range: 3.85 gallons/180 miles (claimed 48mpg at 75mph)
Alternatives: Aprilia RSV4 Factory, £14,999; Ducati 1198S, £16,000; Honda Fireblade, £9,221; Kawasaki
ZX-10R Ninja, £9,245; Suzuki GSX-R1000, £9,800; Yamaha YZF-R1, £10,999
Verdict: An awesome achievement – this bike feels like home, then goes on to perform at the very pinnacle of the class while offering a new generation of electronics at a lower price than anyone was expecting"